I finished this book by Mark Batterson last week and thought you might be interested to read my thoughts on it. Before I go any further, let me say this:
1. I enjoy the wisdom that Mark shares on his blog- I read it daily. So please don’t take the criticism to mean that I don’t appreciate the great stuff that he is pointing out there that encourages and trains others.
2. I am not a published author, so although in some cases I am critical of the book, I also acknowledge that he has done something that I have never even had the opportunity to do.
That said, this book is like much of many of the other Christian self-help books that get written each year and suck ed up by millions of faithful Christians looking for something new to help them turn their lives around. The focus of Batterson’s book is Benaiah, who, according to 2 Samuel 23:20 ff, kills two Moabites warriors, a giant Egyptian armed with a spear- while Benaiah only has a club and- as the title of the book says, kills a lion in a pit on a snowy day.
Batterson makes some great points in this book from a psychological perspective. Having been trained as a therapist myself I know the power of reframing. He encourages the readers to overcome their fears, look for God-given opportunities, try to do something extraordinary. This is a message that we need to hear proclaimed through megaphones, not in isolated corners. Too much is wrong in world for us to sit back and let it continue to slide down the slippery slope. I also really appreciated the stories of “lion chasers” that he shared throughout- it really help to hear about the boldness in ours.
But the thing that gets me about this book is that from exegetical perspective, Batterson creates too much from the simple lines written about Benaiah. It reminds of the book written years ago about the prayer of Jabez. In similar fashion, Batterson talks about Benaiah’s prayer life and how he learned to pray from David. It may very well have happened this way, but we have no proof that it did. Several other times, in telling the story of Benaiah, Batterson enters into speculation in order to help the visuals leap from the page. It certain makes for an exciting read. But it seemed like some of the storyline that Batterson created was used to help him include the applications that we need to make in our lives. In other words, he had the cart before the horse.
So why share this? I want readers to be aware of the liberties that are taken in this book. Is the book good? Yep. I would I recommend it to some one who is struggling with fear and doubt? Yep. Was it worth the read? Sure- the book is less than 200 pages.
My ultimate recommendation would be to read this book if you really struggle with facing your fears, having boldness in Christ or if you stuck and trying to find the opportunity that God is leading you to- this book may just help you find it. But I would highly recommend to everyone that you check out Mark’s blog. He shares a wealth of information each week that is well worth the read.
Recent Comments